http://furbetterfurworse.wordpress.com/2013/09/02/is-buying-from-a-breeder-bad/
And I really liked it, but it got me thinking about a few things. You see, I am one of those evil people: a breeder. That's right, I deliberately and with great forethought, take the boy dog to the girl dog and make puppies. Even worse, I breed OTHER animals too, like chickens, and rabbits, and goats... Yes, I do health checks, I screen prospective buyers, and I have carefully written contracts with carefully thought out consequences and take-back policies, trying my best to protect the little ones I bring into the world. But I also want to expand on a subject that the author of this piece only touched on, and that is: what happens with puppies once they leave us.
I have been breeding dogs under my own kennel name now for almost 40 years. And through that life, I have developed many friendships like the ones this author talks about. I have many people who came to me to buy puppies and became dear friends, who call me in the dark of the night for advice when their dog is throwing up, or send me photos of themselves and their pups, now grown, having all sorts of wonderful adventures. This is why I do this; because I am in the 'business' of creating someone's Best Friend Ever, and when I hit the mark, we all win. Some of them are my very best friends in this world; people that I know would drop everything and be here if something awful happened, who would take over and take care of my animals in the event I was ever unable to, and for whom I would cheerfully and instantly do the same. We scuzzy, evil breeder types, we tend to stick together.
Over all this time, I have seen puppy buyers and pet owners in general grow steadily more savvy. On the one hand, this is great! It is what I, and my other scummy evil breeder friends, have been working towards all our lives. On the other hand though, there really is such a thing as too much knowledge. Or more often, too much misinformation masquerading as knowledge.
See, today's puppy buyers are more educated than they used to be. Problem is, the majority of them get all their information, or the bulk of it, from the internet. Yes, there is a whole lot of really helpful information out there, but there is also a whole lot of myth and propaganda, and the problem is, for the ignorant (not stupid, just unlearned) puppy buyer, they have no way to really determine which sites are helpful and which are just self aggrandizing piffle. I get so tired of sites that purport to educate you on how to tell a 'good breeder' from a 'bad breeder' using a paint by numbers formula. No person I know has a paint by numbers life, so trying to get breeders to fit in neat little boxes is just wrongheaded. Different breeds have very different needs and considerations in care and management, and a breeder's choices will reflect this. Furthermore, the amount of actually hurtful advice is just amazing.
But worst of all, these sites tell you what 'reputable people' will ask, and expect from their puppy buyers, and while many of them hit the mark, there is a largely unnoticed downside with this information: The buyer who has all the right answers, pat in his head, fresh from that internet site, who will fill the breeder full of absolute HOGWASH about what his intentions and expectations are with the puppy, only to take it home, put it in the back yard, and toss food at it once a day. Hopefully. These people are surly and truculent when the breeder calls back to check and see how they are doing together. They are not interested in a long term relationship with the breeder any more than they are with that nice kid from Target who sold them the toaster. The magazines all say that upwardly mobile couples have 2 dogs and 1.3 cats, and if they could figure out how to keep 1/3 of a cat alive, they would do that... the dog is not a family member, it is window dressing. Sort of living lawn art.
Two years later, this animal has had NO decent socialization, NO training, and NO enrichment, and it is all grown up and not going to get any cuter. It barks, it digs, it chews, it nips the kids. It has been raised on the cheapest kibble available at the local grocery, supplemented with kitchen scraps, instead of on the quality feed the breeder suggested. Routine wormings and vet care? Are you kidding, that costs MONEY. Consequently, the pup has developed bone growth disorders, endocrine issues and bad skin from the poor quality feed and parasites. None of this is good for the pup, or for its attitude. Think how YOU would feel if you itched and hurt all the time, and lived with chronic diarrhea and stomach cramps, because you were denied the nutrients you needed to grow properly and were full of nasty worms. Think what kind of temperament you might have, if your only interaction with humans was once a day when they came out the back door, and kicked at you to get you to stop jumping on them, and cursed at you for getting them dirty, while they slapped a pan of poor grade kibble with leftover pancakes on the ground and refilled your rancid water dish. It is not conducive to a loving and outgoing attitude, now is it? All of this will be laid at the breeder's door for selling 'unhealthy puppies' with 'bad genes.' If the breeder is lucky, the buyer will simply return the pup, and the breeder can then begin the grueling process of getting it healthy again and trying to find a DECENT home, winnowing through all the rest of the smiling, LYING people who claim to want a quality pet, but really want a trophy that barks. If the breeder is UNlucky, the poor pup will be dumped at the local shelter or foisted off on some unsuspecting person on Craigslist (in violation of the contract they painstakingly spelled out when the buyer bought the pup.) Good luck getting that contract upheld in court; few courts understand or have any patience with dog contracts. In the world of courts, if you bought it, and paid money for it, then it is yours to do with as you please. They do not understand, nor tend to honor, *conditional* agreements in these documents, no matter how many 'whereas' and 'wherefores' you might insert.
Now that our unlucky pup is in the shelter, it becomes the poster child for poor breeders everywhere. Is any of this the fault of the owner? NO, it is all on that scummy, evil breeder who just shipped that pup off for filthy lucre to the first person to hand them a check! "Look at how awful this pup is, how poorly developed, how crappy the skin and coat is. It has a simply awful temperament too, sitting in the corner shivering. And this horrid breeder foisted this pup off on someone and deemed it healthy and a decent representative of its breed! Just LOOK at the way it moves; I am sure it has HD, hell you can see from here it has rickets." If this pup gets into breed rescue, the unfortunate truth is that those in the kennel club who are gunning for this breeder will be THRILLED to share all this horror with as many people in the breed as they can. With any luck, they can get this scourge kicked out of the club and banned for life. Scummy puppy mill...
As I said, I have been raising dogs for almost 40 years. I have watched this little scenario play itself out many times. I have watched as many good, caring breeders have given up, laid it all to the side and said, "I'm done" (and Ingrid Newkirk laughs in delight.) I have watched as the animal rights nitwits and their sleazy propaganda about breeders has all but destroyed the once-warm connection between puppy buyers and breeders. We are no longer good, knowledgeable people who love and live for our dogs, and who provide a valuable service: that of producing healthy, well bred puppies for people to love. No, we are evil scuzzy breeders, only one step above pond scum, who prostitute our charges for profit, and nothing else. I have also seen all too many breeders release pups into homes that seemed perfect, but later down the line, they turn out to be not just imperfect, but utterly devoid of humanity. Sometimes this is due to changes in fortunes, such as a death in the family, the loss of a job, a divorce. You do not really know a person, not in the depths of their soul, until they have seen some adversity. Sometimes though, it was simply a liar who knew all the right things to say, all the right buttons to push. Sometimes, they learned it from going through breeder after breeder until they figured out what NOT to say, in order to get the next breeder to let them go home with a pup. Lately, however, there are plenty of websites that tell them straight up what the issues are, what a breeder wants from them... so they say what they have to, and they give the breeder their money, and then they proceed to take the dog home and ignore everything they just said, and signed. "After all, who do they think they are? Stupid breeders, they are only in this for the money anyway. Why should they dictate what I do with my dog? I bought it, it's MINE."
Shelter 'logic' is that bad homes are always the result of a bad breeder, somewhere down the line. Either the breeding should never have happened in the first place, or the dog is in a bad home because the BREEDER failed. Let me ask you something: How many of you reading this, have failed marriages, or friends whose marriages failed when you thought they were the perfect couple? How many of you spent MONTHS courting that spouse, and you *thought* you knew them, and you *thought* that this was someone you wanted to spend a lifetime with. What happened? Are you stupid, for mistaking their careful game face for the reality, when they lied and covered up who they really were? Are you stupid, for loving someone at one point in their life, only to find that both of you grew in different ways and you are just not compatible any more? How many marriages fail, how many divorces rip families apart, devastating not just the couple, but the children and the extended family too? Lots of them, right? And yet, you want to opine that dog breeders, who meet these people and interview them at best a few times on the phone and in person, are not doing enough to make SURE it is a good, forever home. What the heck do you expect of us? Why is ALL of this on us, hey?? Even if it is EXTENSIVE interviewing, it does not rise to going to LIVE with them for years first, and even that is no guarantee... How can you expect us to have these God-like powers of perception, and see through the cock and bull, or precog that job loss in five years, and the resulting alcoholism that will make a previously good home suddenly spiral down and collapse, leaving the dog in the lurch?
People need to be more realistic in their expectations, and that applies across the board. You need to be realistic about what a breeder can, and cannot do, about making sure of a 'good home.' You need to be realistic about what a breeder CAN do, in the event that a home they thought was good, suddenly turns out not to be, or a good situation morphs into a bad one. Sometimes, all the take-back contracts in the world will not suffice, if the breeder is themselves facing a family member in end stage liver disease, or trying to retrieve a few of their things in the aftermath of a natural disaster, or in the midst of some kind of personal crisis. Are they terrible people if they fail to live up to promises made in rosier times, when they thought they would "always" have room, and time, to take back any puppy they ever produced? When it comes down to taking back the puppy, or being there for Grandma as she dies, who wins, and is the breeder a scumball if they choose Grandma? What if the breeder themselves develops health issues, rendering them incapable of living up to that contract? Well, how DARE she have a car accident and end up crippled! Lying scummy BREEDER...
You also need to be more realistic about the reasons dogs come into shelters or rescue; it is NOT all because the breeder failed in their trust. Generally speaking, it is not the BREEDER bringing the dog in, now is it? No, it is usually either the owner, or a family member. In the worst scenarios, it is like the cat I just took in; the treasured pet of an old gentleman who had the misfortune to be related to some really useless people. When he suddenly passed, their answer for what to do with the pets who made his last years worth living were: "Dispose of them." And that is the BREEDER's fault, yeah, for bringing those cats into the world? For sending them to live with an old gent who loved them dearly but then had the bad grace to die and leave them behind? Uh, no.
Dog breeders are not evil, but neither are they omniscient. We are human, and while we care deeply for each and every puppy we produce, and while we cry bitterly once the new family takes it home, there is only so much that we can control. We can only do the best we can, and hope for the best. The only other alternative is no puppies for ANYONE to love, and while I know the animal rights crowd lives for this day, and thinks it's just great, I do not think that MOST of us, the people out here in reality land, would agree with them. At least I hope not.
Edited to add: I have received an unprecedented amount of appreciation for this piece, and I have been asked if it can be crossposted, so I am including a 'permission to crosspost' for those who found this compelling. Thank you for the kind words.



